Nature vs Nurture: Some Thoughts on the White Supremacy Movement

Warning: This is fully 100% conjecture and opinions that I don't have any significant amount of backing for (as usual). Feel free to verbally destroy me with intimate knowledge, scientific studies and scary numbers. But if you choose to do so, please be nice...I'm rather sensitive :(

We often talk about the idea of nature vs nurture - whether our genes or our environment are the determinants of our psychology. For all the debate out there, I feel that it is (or should be) reasonably obvious that both play a significant role in shaping our world view and personality (i.e they're not mutually exclusive). Moreover, the two interact with each other - it is in our nature to adapt and learn from the environment in which we live. That innate ability to adapt is what has made us such a versatile and successful species.

Personally, I often find myself falling on the side of nature when thinking about these things. Part of the reason why is because I really do view humans as one views animals - driven by primal desires to survive and propagate genes. This is consistent with my evolutionary worldview (that consistency being a worthy exchange for the large quantities of cynicism this type of thinking brings). The nice thing is that even if humans are ultimately animals, I'm one of them and understand their language and individuality. I also think that we have a lot more complexity and layers, so much so that connecting our actions to those primal instincts can often be difficult or impossible.

There's one more caveat to my view. I sometimes feel that we're outgrowing some of those instincts, and slowly (or rapidly in geological age), we're finding enough distractions to give life a new meaning. And our emotions are what drive us to that meaning. But I'm not sure, and maybe those emotions just ultimately tie back to a primal instinct.

As a more specific example, a lot of us have made it our life's purpose to be joyful. This makes sense to me. Joy feels good. But maybe joy exists so we re-do what we just did to bring us that joy? Maybe this is important because whatever we did pertains to survival or gene propagation. It's easy to imagine in social settings. I imagine that the nice homo sapiens sitting around their fire 100'000 years ago felt joy in each other's company just as we do sitting around a pub table sharing drinks and food with friends. That feeling of joy would encourage them to seek that experience again, and thus strengthen those bonds with their fellow tribesmen. Social bonds directly led to survival (like when your buddy saves you from a lion), as well as gene propagation/protection of offspring.

Maybe the link to modern day is direct. Like when your buddy saves you on the math exam, thus letting you pass engineering, thus reaching the promised land of attractive ladies and a successful life (note: it's a lie). But likely it's not that simple. What is clear to me though, is that our survival has always been incumbent on social interactions, and that's why our emotions are so sensitive in social settings.

Two Rivers - pt. 4

Alam Zawar
32-A Sarwar Shaheed Rd, Icchra
Lahore, Punjab
Pakistan

14th December 2005

Dear Alam,

What's Lahore like? What school are you going to? How many classmates do you have? What are you learning? Did you make any friends? Can you speak Punjabi yet?

Everyone here is fine! It's gotten cold now, and it snowed yesterday.

We all miss you so much. Especially Bilal. He was really angry and sad when he found out you were gone. Don't tell him I told you, but he was even crying. Didn't you tell him you were leaving? Now he's so lonely. I think he's sad you never said goodbye. You should write to him. Oh, Jamal says he's sad too.

Ami is always talking about you. She wanted Abu to call you every day, but he said he doesn't want to disturb Uncle Masood. That's why I asked him to get your address, so I can write to you. Make sure you reply. Send your letter to Uncle Gulzar and he can give it to us when he comes on a tour. I made him write down his address, it's on the other piece of paper in this envelope. Do you remember how to write a letter? Make sure you do it right.

I hope you're behaving. Abu was so grateful to Uncle Masood. He told us that Uncle Zubair tricked us. Did that really happen? He seemed like such a nice man. Anyway, Abu really likes Uncle Masood so make sure you work hard for him.

The glaciers are going to block off the road soon, so I might not be able to write to you again before Spring. Until then, take care of yourself and say all of your prayers.

Much love,
Mina